I Think The Name For This Model Should Be The “Post-Modern” Golf Swing

When you think about it, the Mike Dunaway-style golf swing still does have a free and full hip turn, but it doesn’t look anything like your typical “Classic Golf Swing” model.

I mean, if someone were to ask me to demonstrate a Classic Golf Swing, I would hardly rack up Dunaway’s model, would I?

And it is definitely not a Modern Golf Swing model, because of the hip and leg action and the lack of a lower back twist.

His earliest swing model that we have seen, from Sybervision, is more Classic model:


That model is more like the Late Hogan model, which still utilized a Shift & Post hip and leg action but still very closely resembles your familiar Classic Golf Swing.

I’m talking about this model here:


Considering that it has only really been performed by Mike Dunaway (yes, Ben Hogan in his Late swing model and some others had the same pivot action but more in the Classic Golf Swing style in their execution), the next person we see swinging in this manner will be the first since him.

I think a good name for it would be “Post-Modern,” since – if I am correct in my analysis and modeling at the moment – it may be the first golf swing model to be practiced widely since the arrival of the Modern Golf Swing sometime around 1990.

I am not forgetting the Stack & Tilt swing model or any of its imitators, because it is not a mechanically-sound model, and so doesn’t merit inclusion in a separate category from the Modern Golf Swing models which are also mechanically unsound.

Just a thought.

On another note, I am baffled when I re-watch the Austin and Dunaway swing videos, because it doesn’t take a multi-hour presentation to teach this swing motion.

You have the following:

  • Grip
  • Setup
  • Pivot Action
  • Down Swing Transition
  • Impact (or the Swing Bottom) and the Finish

That goes for my former videos as well – I have made a commitment that in any future video projects, I might not be a brutally succinct as I am in “The Basics Of The MCS Golf Swing,” which lay out how to perform that transitional Shift & Post pivot of the “Late Hogan” pivot action in a Classic Golf Swing, but then again, I can’t think of anything I have left out that would have made it longer, other than needlessly repeating things and going off on tangents.

I think people tend to fall into the trap of, “more gives greater value,” when in actuality, the most important parts of videos are sandwiched in between needless points and blather that I now feel distract from the purpose at hand – presenting the material the way a textbook would, and to which one refer as many times as one wishes or needs to.

 

4 thoughts on “I Think The Name For This Model Should Be The “Post-Modern” Golf Swing

    1. DJ Watts's avatarDJ Watts Post author

      I don’t think it matters if someone does, AK – I would like to have a name to different it from the Classic swing, but someone else trademarking the name only gets them the name.

      What matters most to me is the mechanics of the swing. I could simply call it the swing based on Mike Dunaway’s model… and it would still be the same thing.

      A rose by any other name… 😁

      PS – am I really quoting Shakespeare now? 😂😂

      Reply
  1. Michael's avatarMichael

    Hi,

    I can see that they’re different but the actions between the classic golf swing and dunaway’s shift and post look pretty similar. I can’t quite put my finger on the technical verbiage to describe the differences between these two. The pivots look the same so what exactly is going on that makes them different? Is the only difference that dunaway is just staying on his back foot longer which results in the delayed step-around versus the classic swing back foot slide or is there something else going on also? Thanks either way. As always, love your stuff.

    Reply
    1. DJ Watts's avatarDJ Watts Post author

      Well they’re both golf swings, Michael, so they will look “similar” whatever is going on.

      People think the Modern Golf Swing is based upon Ben Hogan’s swing and they couldn’t be more incorrect, as I have taken great pains to point out.

      The Classic Golf swing uses a purely rotary hip turn, the Shift & Post action creates the hip turn without a rotary motion, rather a shift and creation of a “post” with the trail leg then the leading leg, which is why Dunaway’s trail foot stayed down so long but without doing it deliberately.

      That’s essentially the difference, but a difference profound enough to differentiate one from the other.

      Reply

Leave a reply to AK Cancel reply